
Sedona Pines Resort
Best for families and anyone who wants a cottage with a full kitchen, on-site mini golf, and a very large heated pool.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Sedona Pines Resort is a 3.5-star cottage resort on West State Route 89A made up of individual casitas and family-oriented amenities; read this if you want a self-contained cottage with a big heated pool and activities for kids. Best Western Plus Arroyo Roble Hotel & Creekside Villas is a 2.5-star branded Uptown Sedona property that pairs standard hotel rooms with creekside villas and red-rock views; read this if you want Uptown convenience, creekside settings, and a familiar chain experience.
Updated

Best for families and anyone who wants a cottage with a full kitchen, on-site mini golf, and a very large heated pool.

Best for guests who want Uptown Sedona access, a mix of hotel rooms and multi-bedroom villas, and conveniences like free buffet breakfast and meeting space.
When Sedona Pines Resort wins: choose Sedona Pines when you want a cottage-style unit with a full kitchen, on-site family recreation (18-hole mini golf, playground), multiple hot tubs, and one of Sedona’s largest heated pools.
When Best Western Plus Arroyo Roble wins: pick Best Western Plus Arroyo Roble if you want to stay in Uptown Sedona near galleries and restaurants, need a branded-hotel setup (onsite meeting space, business center), or prefer a property that offers a daily complimentary buffet breakfast and villa-style suites with kitchens.
Bottom line: both are practical bases for exploring Sedona’s red rocks — Sedona Pines leans toward cottage living and family recreation on West Sedona, while Best Western Plus Arroyo Roble offers Uptown convenience, creekside villas, and the predictability of a national brand.
| Category | Sedona Pines Resort | Best Western Plus Arroyo Roble Hotel & Creekside Villas |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Cottage-resort on West Sedona with family recreation and casitas | Branded Uptown hotel with a mix of hotel rooms and creekside villas |
| Location | West State Route 89A (West Sedona); closer to Red Rock State Park and some trailheads | Uptown Sedona (400 North State Route 89A); walking distance to galleries and visitor services |
| Size / rooms | About 148–153 individual cottages/casitas across the property (sources vary) | 66 air-conditioned rooms and a mix of hotel rooms plus creekside villas |
| Who it suits | Families or groups wanting kitchen-equipped cottages and on-site activities | Visitors who want Uptown convenience, some full-kitchen villas, and free breakfast |
| Pools & hot tubs | Large heated saltwater outdoor pool plus multiple hot tubs; at least one adult-only hot tub reported | Outdoor seasonal pool, 2 hot tubs and a sauna |
| Dining & bars | On-site Bella Vita Ristorante (Italian dinner) and a lounge bar; restaurant is an adjacent, separately operated business | Snack bar/deli and complimentary buffet breakfast; no named signature restaurant listed |
| Wellness & fitness | On-site fitness facility; hot tubs; conflicting sources about a full-service spa (no verified spa name) | Fitness facilities, sauna, hot tubs; no named full-service spa published |
| Family features | Gated playground, mini golf (18 holes), family-friendly programming | Arcade/game room and playground on site |
| Accessibility & services | Wheelchair-accessible parking and registration desk; free WiFi; concierge and tour assistance | Wheelchair-accessible public spaces and fitness center; concierge, business center, free WiFi |
| Parking & transport | Free self parking on site | Self parking (surcharge) and off-street parking |
Sedona Pines Resort sits on West State Route 89A at the western edge of town and is positioned for quick drives to Red Rock State Park and Cathedral Rock.
Better if you want proximity to West Sedona trailheads and a quieter, spread-out cottage property.
Best Western Plus Arroyo Roble is in Uptown Sedona near galleries, restaurants, and visitor services.
Better if you want to be in the center of Uptown Sedona with easier access to dining and galleries.
Sedona Pines is built from individual cottages and casitas, each with a full kitchen and living space.
Choose Sedona Pines for kitchen-equipped, cottage-style accommodation and more private, spread-out units.
Best Western Plus Arroyo Roble offers a mix of standard hotel rooms and multi-bedroom villas with kitchens.
Pick Best Western Plus Arroyo Roble if you want flexible room types from standard hotel rooms to villa-style suites with kitchens.
Sedona Pines lists Bella Vita Ristorante as the resort’s on-site Italian restaurant (operated as a separate business) plus an on-site lounge bar.
Better if you want an evening-focused Italian restaurant on or adjacent to property and don’t need included breakfast.
Best Western Plus Arroyo Roble includes a complimentary buffet breakfast and a snack bar/deli on site.
Better if you value a free morning buffet and simple on-site deli options.
Sedona Pines highlights a very large heated saltwater outdoor pool plus multiple hot tubs and family activities.
Better for families and guests who want a sizable pool and on-site activities for kids.
Best Western Plus Arroyo Roble offers an outdoor seasonal pool, two hot tubs and fitness amenities.
Better if you want standard hotel-style pool amenities with a sauna and hot tubs in Uptown.
Sedona Pines provides fitness facilities and multiple hot tubs, with some ambiguity around presence of a full-service spa.
Better if you want fitness and hot-tub relaxation but not depending on a named treatment spa on site.
Best Western Plus Arroyo Roble lists fitness facilities, a sauna, hot tubs, and no named full-service spa.
Better if you want basic wellness facilities plus business conveniences in Uptown Sedona.

Sedona Pines — larger heated saltwater pool, gated playground, mini golf, and cottage-style units with kitchens.

Best Western Plus Arroyo Roble — located in Uptown within short distance of galleries, restaurants, and visitor amenities.

Sedona Pines — full kitchens in individual cottages make it easy to self-cater for families or longer visits.

Best Western Plus Arroyo Roble — complimentary buffet breakfast and 904 sq ft of meeting space for small events or business travelers.
Sedona Pines Resort — it has an 18-hole mini golf course, a gated playground, a very large heated pool and family-oriented cottage units with kitchens.
Best Western Plus Arroyo Roble — it sits in Uptown Sedona close to gallery row, Sedona Arts Center, and nearby restaurants.
Best Western Plus lists hot tubs and a sauna; Sedona Pines has multiple hot tubs and some sources mention spas but no named, verified full-service spa or treatment menus were found for either property.
Yes — Sedona Pines cottages include full kitchens; Best Western Plus also offers several villa and suite options listed as having full kitchens.
Explore how Sedona Pines Resort stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·