
Sedona Pines Resort
Best for families and groups who want separate cottage space, on-site recreation (mini-golf, playground) and cooking facilities.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Sedona Pines Resort is a 3.5-star cottage-style resort on West State Route 89A with individual casitas, family recreation, and an on-site Italian restaurant; read this if you want roomy self-catered units and activities for kids. Amara Resort and Spa is a 4.5-star upscale, spa-focused resort in Uptown Sedona with a full-service spa and a single signature restaurant; read this if you want a centrally located, spa-centered stay and easy access to Uptown shops and galleries.
Updated

Best for families and groups who want separate cottage space, on-site recreation (mini-golf, playground) and cooking facilities.

Best for travelers who want a central Uptown base with a full-service spa, poolside bar, and easy access to Sedona galleries and restaurants.
When Sedona Pines Resort wins: choose Sedona Pines if you need one- or two-bedroom cottages with full kitchens, want on-site family recreation (18-hole mini-golf, playground, large heated saltwater pool) and prefer West Sedona’s quieter, spread-out property.
When Amara Resort and Spa wins: choose Amara if you prioritize an on-site full-service spa, a creekside/up-town location within walking distance of galleries and restaurants, and a boutique-upscale hotel experience with a single signature restaurant (SaltRock Kitchen).
Bottom line: pick Sedona Pines for space, family amenities, and self-catering cottages; pick Amara for spa services, a central Uptown address, and a more compact, upscale hotel environment.
| Category | Sedona Pines Resort | Amara Resort and Spa |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Casita/cottage resort spread across grounds; family- and activity-oriented. | Upscale, spa-forward hotel with a boutique, Uptown feel. |
| Location | West Sedona on State Route 89A; convenient to Red Rock State Park and Crescent Moon Ranch. | Uptown Sedona (100 Amara Lane); walking distance to galleries, Tlaquepaque and local dining. |
| Size (units) | About 148–153 individual cottages (sources vary). | 100 rooms (supplier listing). |
| Ages / Audience | All ages; family-friendly with playground and children’s activities. | All ages; not adults-only (supplier listing: adultsOnly = false). |
| Pools & hot tubs | Large heated saltwater outdoor pool and multiple hot tubs; at least one adult-only hot tub reported. | One outdoor pool, hot tub and poolside bar; free pool cabanas available (supplier listing). |
| Restaurants & bars | Bella Vita Ristorante (Italian) on/adjacent to property; an on-site lounge bar is listed. | SaltRock Kitchen (on-site restaurant) with bar/lounge and poolside bar; room service available (limited hours). |
| Spa & wellness | No confirmed full-service treatment spa (sources disagree); fitness center on-site. | Full-service spa with massage, body treatments, facials, plus sauna and steam room (supplier listing). |
| Known for | Individual cottages with full kitchens, mini-golf, family recreation and large heated pool. | Upscale spa offerings, creekside rooms and a central Uptown location near galleries. |
| Accessibility & parking | Wheelchair-accessible parking and registration desk; single-level cottages (no elevator); free self parking. | Multiple accessible features (wheelchair-accessible path, pool, restaurant); valet parking (surcharge) and limited accessible parking spaces. |
| Meeting / events | No named meeting rooms found; some OTAs list meeting/banquet facilities and business center. | Three meeting rooms available (supplier listing). |
Sedona Pines sits on West State Route 89A on the western edge of town, convenient for Red Rock State Park and trailheads.
Choose Sedona Pines if you want easier driving access to trailheads and a more spread-out, quiet property.
Amara Resort and Spa is in Uptown Sedona, steps from galleries, shops and restaurants.
Choose Amara if you want an Uptown base to explore Sedona without driving for every meal or gallery visit.
Sedona Pines offers individual modular cottages and a few room types focused on one- and two-bedroom layouts.
Choose Sedona Pines for larger, self-contained cottage units and kitchen facilities.
Amara has hotel-style rooms and suites (100 rooms) with a range of patios and creekside options.
Choose Amara if you prefer hotel-style rooms with spa and creekside room options rather than self-catering cottages.
Sedona Pines guests use Bella Vita Ristorante (Italian) for dinner and there’s a lounge bar associated with dining.
Choose Sedona Pines if you want an Italian dinner option adjacent to your cottages and prefer a relaxed, local-restaurant setup.
Amara’s dining is centered on SaltRock Kitchen with a garden view, poolside bar and limited room service.
Choose Amara if you want an on-site signature restaurant and easy access to Uptown dining after a spa day.
Sedona Pines emphasizes family recreation with a very large heated saltwater pool, multiple hot tubs and games.
Pick Sedona Pines for family-friendly recreation and a large pool area with multiple onsite activities.
Amara offers a single outdoor pool with hot tub, poolside bar, free pool cabanas and free bicycles on site.
Pick Amara if you want a resort-style pool with a poolside bar and a smaller, more intimate pool setting.
Sedona Pines provides fitness facilities and hot tubs, but evidence for a dedicated full-service spa is mixed.
Choose Sedona Pines for fitness and hot-tub relaxation; don’t expect a confirmed full-service treatment spa on site.
Amara lists a full-service spa with massages, body treatments and facials plus steam and sauna.
Choose Amara if you want an on-site full-service spa and spa-focused amenities.

Sedona Pines — cottages, playground, mini-golf and a very large heated pool make this the easier family pick.

Amara Resort and Spa — a full-service spa with treatment rooms, sauna and steam room is clearly listed.

Amara Resort and Spa — located in Uptown Sedona close to galleries, Tlaquepaque and local dining.

Sedona Pines — individual cottages with full kitchens and one- and two-bedroom layouts make longer or family stays easier.
Sedona Pines — it has a gated playground, mini-golf, a very large heated pool and cottage layouts that suit families.
Amara Resort and Spa lists a full-service spa with massages, body treatments and facials. Sedona Pines’ listing is inconsistent about a treatment spa (sources describe hot tubs but not a named full-service spa).
Sedona Pines cottages include full kitchens or kitchenettes. Amara’s rooms are hotel-style with minibars; full kitchens are not listed in the supplier facts.
Amara is in Uptown Sedona and is listed within walking distance of galleries and Tlaquepaque; Sedona Pines is on West State Route 89A and is a short drive from many attractions.
Explore how Sedona Pines Resort stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·